Will loss of AI-specific liability rules leave victims without redress?

The Artificial Intelligence Act came into unit successful the EU successful August 2024, defining 4 levels of hazard for AI systems: unacceptable, high, constricted and minimal. Eight practices are banned arsenic unacceptable based on behaviour or idiosyncratic characteristics, and these bans came into effect this month.

There are galore different imaginable risks arising from AI to health, information and cardinal rights, and a connection was intended to make a harmonised ineligible attack crossed subordinate states for those seeking compensation. But the circumstantial directive is astatine superior risk.

"The European Commission published its enactment programme for 2025 a fewer weeks ago, and the directive was connected the database to beryllium withdrawn. They don't deliberation it has made capable advancement and won't marque capable advancement successful the coming months," explains Cynthia Kroet, who follows EU exertion argumentation for euronews.

While immoderate reason that consumers would inactive beryllium capable to invoke the Product Liability Directive, "there is simply a large quality due to the fact that this directive lone covers defective products, worldly damage. AI liability would screen errors made, for example, by an algorithm that would pb to discriminatory results from an AI system," according to Kroet.

Citizens interviewed by euronews successful Madrid and Budapest appeared to expect a ineligible information net. "I deliberation it's an highly absorbing technology, but besides precise unsafe if it's not decently regulated," said a nonmigratory of the Spanish capital.

“We should surely marque ineligible decisions that prohibit, for example, a tiny kid from harming oregon harassing different with artificial intelligence,” suggested a Budapest resident.

Does excessively overmuch regularisation impact competitiveness?

Dropping the AI ​​Accountability Directive could beryllium a motion that the European Commission is listening to critics who accidental excessively overmuch regularisation hurts concern competitiveness.

To code this, President Ursula von der Leyen announced a caller money during the AI ​​Global acme successful Paris successful aboriginal February. Called InvestAI, it volition mobilise €200 cardinal to concern 4 aboriginal AI gigafactories successful the EU. A twelve smaller units are besides planned, allowing companies to trial their AI models.

Brando Benifei, a centre-left Italian MEP, said withdrawal of the directive was a "disappointing prime due to the fact that it creates ineligible uncertainty". The AI ​​Law’s rapporteur does not see regularisation successful the database of factors that harm competitiveness.

"We person little entree to superior for concern successful the integer sector. We request much computing infrastructure and past we request simplified and wide rules. But we cannot springiness up connected protecting our citizens, our businesses, our nationalist institutions, our ideology from the risks of discrimination, disinformation, harm from the misuse of AI," helium told euronews.

While the European Commission is unfastened to uncovering a solution, the legislator besides believes that a circumstantial directive connected liability would beryllium the champion “way forward” and describes it arsenic “light legislation that tin make a communal minimum standard”.

Benifei says that the "recommendations" unsocial would beryllium ignored by immoderate subordinate states and changing Product Liability authorities could beryllium complicated.

The AI ​​Act volition beryllium afloat applicable by 2027, meantime the EU wants to support up of the innovation race, but tin the Union equilibrium its tendency to beryllium an AI powerhouse portion besides protecting the rights of its citizens?

Watch the video here!

Journalist: Isabel Marques da Silva

Content production: Pilar Montero López

Video production: Zacharia Vigneron

Graphism: Loredana Dumitru

Editorial coordination: Ana Lázaro Bosch and Jeremy Fleming-Jones