5 days ago
17
The ongoing nationalist treatment astir the 2019 authorities outlining the cognition of the so-called “executive state” whitethorn look new, but it is fundamentally recycling an aged issue. Given that the attraction of enforcement powerfulness successful the premier minister’s bureau has been an unquestionable staple since the restoration of democracy, the existent contented astatine manus is: How is this powerfulness organized and exercised so that it does not beryllium connected the temperament of each premier minister, but connected the rules, procedures and mechanisms that springiness it structure and constraints?
Since the start of the Metapolitefsi, Greece has operated with a system that is parliamentary successful signifier but is efficaciously centered connected the premier curate successful practice. In different words, powerfulness tends to beryllium concentrated successful the bureau of the premier minister, who is not conscionable the caput of the government, but besides the full system’s main moderator: He sets the priorities, keeps the equilibrium successful the enactment and, often, makes up for shortfalls successful the administration. The effect of this is that governance was shaped by the strengths and weaknesses of the antheral astatine the top for decades. Power has ever been centralized; it is the mode of centralization that has varied. When premier ministers person been powerful, the system rotated astir them. When they’ve been comparatively weak, aggregate powerfulness centers typically emerged within the governing party, the furniture and the parliamentary group.
Since the start of the Metapolitefsi, Greece has operated with a system that is parliamentary successful signifier but is efficaciously centered connected the premier curate successful practice
Konstantinos Karamanlis is simply a diagnostic illustration of the former. He personally monitored the work of each ministry and regularly called enforcement meetings with ministers, adjacent associates and, where needed, with experts, to draught argumentation oregon negociate crises. Another influential person of the aboriginal Metapolitefsi, Andreas Papandreou, successful contrast, exercised his unquestionable powerfulness much indirectly: He seldom supervised his ministers intimately and they enjoyed a bully woody of autonomy – astatine slightest until this was revoked by the premier curate via the predominant furniture reshuffles helium carried out.
Costas Simitis was the nonstop other of these two leaders. When helium became premier minister, helium recovered that a deficiency of cardinal oversight meant that the authorities functioned arsenic a loose, astir national system, with ministries enjoying wide autonomy from the center. In his ain words, helium envisioned an “executive” government. For this to happen, however, ministerial responsibilities needed to beryllium “systematically transferred and to a important grade to different agencies, so that the ministries themselves could go strategic, steering bodies.” This decentralization proved problematic, however, since the agencies receiving these caller powers were administratively inadequate. Ultimately, the inability to centralize powerfulness did not correspond a strategic prime of strength, but alternatively a regulation of it.
This is the discourse for understanding the instrumentality governing the “executive state.” Let us start by saying that the sanction of the instrumentality itself acts arsenic a symbolic – if not promotional – synopsis alternatively than a precise overview of its content, which is much intelligibly outlined successful the subtitle: “Organization, cognition and transparency of the government, of authorities bodies and of the cardinal nationalist administration.”
The “executive state” model, therefore, by nary means overturns the halfway rule of the post-junta model: Power is centralized by being chiefly successful the hands of the premier minister. The quality lies successful the “technocratic” mode by which that powerfulness is exercised – to use a word galore see anathema. It describes and specifies a mechanics that extends horizontally – crossed the government, governmental bodies and cardinal medication – and seeks to marque this attraction much predictable, much transparent and little babelike connected the foibles of immoderate fixed leadership.
In this sense, it seeks to enactment – present and successful the aboriginal – arsenic a counterweight to some manifestations, by containing tendencies toward the arbitrary ways of over-centralized, charismatic premier ministers, while besides mitigating the dysfunctions produced by the inability of weaker – albeit sufficiently organization – premier ministers to coordinate the work of their government. Instead of shifting where the halfway of powerfulness lies, the conception of the “executive state” introduces and specifies the modes of attraction and the method of its exercise.
But let’s beryllium realistic. Greece is not astir to displacement from the premier minister-centric exemplary anytime soon. Nor is it apt – arsenic is the lawsuit successful different democracies – to get a afloat impersonal, bureaucratically self-sufficient state that functions with adjacent ratio successful times of normalcy oregon crisis, careless of the authorities oregon its leader. That said, a very decentralized, polycentric exemplary where work is fragmented crossed “fiefdom-ministries” is nary λύση either. We person tried this connected respective occasions successful the past and the acquisition was bitter.
The challenge, therefore, is to amended the cognition of a steady organization mechanics that allows the sitting premier curate to coordinate authorities work with consistency and effectiveness. This is what Law 4622/2019 connected the “executive state” aspired to establish. Many weaknesses person emerged successful the years that followed and person been – rather rightly – pointed out, so if we are so realists, let’s hole them.
Takis S. Pappas is simply a governmental idiosyncratic and writer.
Greek (GR) · 
English (US) ·